Ultimate Towing Job
Reprinted from a Facebook post by my friend Mary Kay Dineen, who told me: “Should you need their service, these are my Minnesota relatives. I kid you not.” Written By: Mary Divine / St. Paul Pioneer Press and Linda Vanderwerf / West Central Tribune |
ST. PAUL — Jason Butler, owner of City Line Towing of Willmar, has seen his share of unusual jobs. He has fished pickup trucks out of frozen lakes, pulled snow-covered semitrailers out of ditches and once rescued a capsized double-decker pontoon boat. Now, he’s offered to do something he’s never attempted before — pull a 26-foot sailboat from the ice on the St. Croix River. It was the ultimate towing job.
When he read about about Mike Olson’s plight, he knew he could help. He offered his towing services and expertise — free of charge. Olson, of Chisago City, owns the white-and-blue fiberglass 1977 Pearson sailboat that has been frozen in the St. Croix since Nov. 1.
Butler and a friend, Josh Schafer, division manager of Pulver Towing in Marshall, said they plan to assemble a team to remove the boat in the next few weeks. Butler drove to Stillwater to assess the situation Wednesday morning. On his way back to Willmar, he said the removal would have to wait a few weeks because there’s not enough ice yet to work safely.
Ultimate Towing Job“We hope to have it out, weather permitting, by the middle of December,” he said in a phone interview Wednesday afternoon with the West Central Tribune. The job won’t be easy, he said. The boat has a 4-foot keel on the bottom, so it will have to be lifted about 5 feet above the ice before it can be moved. This effort, “a little out of the ordinary,” is a huge undertaking and will be a group effort with Pulver Towing and others, Butler said of his ultimate towing job.
His plan for now — “We’re going to probably hand-build a lifting system to extract it from the water and then winch the skid to the shoreline.” There are other options possible if the first doesn’t work out, he said. “I can guarantee we’re going to figure it out one way or another,” he said.
A few inches of good ice is needed, he said. Tow trucks are not driven on the ice, and most of his retrieval equipment floats, but “I don’t want to spend a lot of time recovering my own equipment.” River ice is different from lake ice, and Butler said he expects to see a learning curve as the team prepares for the extraction. “It’s going to take us all of a complete day from start to finish,” he said. “I hope we can do it in one day; we’ve never recovered a sailboat out of ice before.”
Earlier this week, Schafer told the St. Paul Pioneer Press, “It’s definitely doable. It will be fun. I can’t wait.” It’s the ultimate towing job.
Ice recoveries are a specialty for Butler and Schafer. “We try to do as many as possible,” Butler told the Pioneer Press. “That’s what we get excited about.” Last year, Butler, Schafer and Matt Maloney, owner of Maloney Enterprises in Madelia, led an effort to pull an ice fisherman’s 7,000-pound pickup truck from the bottom of Lake Shetek near Slayton.
“It’s a challenge for us, especially because it’s on a river,” Butler said. “That’s not in our neck of the woods. … It will be a good training for us.” “I really, really appreciate what they are doing,” Olson told the Pioneer Press. “I was running out of options. He even told me that the boat shouldn’t be damaged when he’s done with it.”
Olson, who doesn’t have insurance, was told the recovery effort could cost about $20,000, which he couldn’t afford. “It’s extremely nice of them,” he said. “I won’t say we’d do this every day for free … but this is a special circumstance,” Butler said. “He seems like he’s in dire need of some help.”
Schafer’s family has owned Rochester-based Pulver Towing since 1922. The company workers jumped at the chance to help. “Hey, this guy’s struggling. Of course we’ll do whatever it takes,” he said. “Everybody in the towing industry is friends. It’s like a brotherhood.”
Plus, he added, “It’s that time of the year.”

Ultimate Towing Job

Sailing with Capt Bill

This email just came in…
Captain Bill, Thought I would share this memento of a previous vacation in which my family spent a day with you. My daughter must have drawn this at the hotel and I thought it worth saving. Two and a half years later I am taking a pic of it to send to you. Guess that means I should hang on to it a bit longer. 
I wish you and your family a great holiday season. Hope to get to sail with you again next season!

Dave Wisman

Ultimate Towing Job

Learning a Boat, not the Towing Job

Bringier at the helm of his new sailboatUltimate Towing JobBringier and Sally McConnell of Queens Lake bought a new-to-them 2006 Hunter 36 and didn’t even have to move it from its slip at York River Yacht Haven. I joined him for a boat orientation that included thru hulls, electronics, lines and more. Out on the river, we found he could slip under the Coleman Bridge at high tide with 5 feet clearance.
We could see six of eight housesWhat was remarkable was how much of the shoreline was visible once most of the leaves had fallen after Thanksgiving. We could see six of the eight officer houses of Naval Weapons Station behind the Colonial Parkway. Normally you’re lucky to see two or three. No towing job here.
He's a bird watcherEven more remarkable was the bird situation. “I’m a bird watcher,” Bringier said, “from our deck in Queens Lake. It was 30 years before I saw any osprey out here because they were nearly extinct from DDT kills. And now we can see pelicans, I never used to see pelicans. The loons are everywhere too.” I suggested that the pelicans, loons and seaguls return in the fall once the osprey have flown south.
With my new Fuji camera, I used the 50x lens to get a close-up of a contemporary house overlooking the river and Naval Weapons Station. Bringier said, “The house a few doors down belongs to a new client of ours, and we were just there for a Christmas party. The view is spectacular.”

Let’s Go Sail the Ultimate Towing Job

Check rates and pick a day for a sailboat charter. See reviews on Trip Advisor. 

Ultimate Towing Job

More from the Captain...

Sailing Safety

Sailing Safety

A hazardous PVC pipe was removed as a prank and dropped into the York River, making it a worse hazard to navigation.

Full Story >